by Carolyn Tillie

During the beginning of June every year, the Napa valley is transformed. There is a palpable feeling that descends upon the 25-mile stretch of Highway 29. It is apparent by the limousines tooling up the mountain roads and the Silverado Trail, the lack of a decent table at any local restaurant, and the excessive display of wealth seen on well-manicured ring fingers. It is, of course, the Napa Valley Auction.  

The Napa Valley Vintner’s Association hosts a number of auctions throughout the year, but Auction Napa Valley is THE premiere fund-raising auction in the country (apparently last year, some silly auction in Florida was a tad bigger and now there is this competition of sorts between Naples, Florida and Napa). This year’s ten million raised will be hard to beat by any one’s reckoning.   

For twenty-five years, the Auction “officially” started on the Wednesday evening before the weekend, with a Wine Spectator-hosted, invitation-only Magnum Party held at Tra Vigne restaurant. Who gets invited? Oh, well-established winery owners, cult winemakers, and other movers-and-shakers in the industry. The caveat? Well, you gotta bring a magnum of ‘your’ wine.  

Then, over the course of the next few days, leading up to The Big Night, there are various and sundry parties held all over the valley. Some are intimate, like dinner for ten with Robert and Magrit Mondavi in their home.  Most tend towards glamour with the hiring of some celebrity chef (last year, there was quite a controversy when Rocco DiSpirito was in the middle of his carwreck of a reality television show, “The Restaurant” and some other chef had to replace him at the last minute). Occasionally, the events get playful like Diamond Constant’s pyjama [sic] party under the stars. But the recurring factor in all these events is the fact that only those with serious capital get to play. The cost for attending the auction? $7,500 a couple. That’s just to get your foot in the door.  

Bear in mind, most attending don’t live in the valley so there is the added expense of accommodations, a new wardrobe for the event, transportation, and – oh, yeah – they actually expect you to bid on an auction item or two. These are items that generally auction off in the range of a hundred-grand or more. One of the more talked-about lots in this year’s auction is the Frank Family offering of a Desperate Housewives walk-on part and dinner with television star Teri Hatcher. Oh yes, a five-year vertical Frank Family wine is thrown it for good cause (three litres of course!). The night of the auction, one woman was bidding so aggressively on that walk-on part, and upset when she lost the lot, that she was ultimately offered  her own walk-on part if she agreed to match the winning bid (she did). 

Scott TracyHaving watched all this excess over the years, Scott Tracy, La Toque’s sommelier, had a brainstorm of an idea in 2002. In answer to that infamous, invitation-only Magnum Party, he would kick off the auction with an entirely irreverent “Half Bottle Party” to be held at the gastronome capital of the Napa Valley, Taylor’s Refresher, St. Helena’s landmark hamburger stand.  The invitation is sent valley-wide via e-mail with the instructions: Come and buy a lot of food and bring a half-bottle to share. If your winery doesn’t produce half-bottles, then dump out half a bottle of something. No full bottles allowed. No auction paddles. No auction lots. No RSVP’s. Just good wine with good people and good food. 

Gary GraceHow could this intrepid reporter refuse such an auspicious invitation? With a half bottle of Ladera’s 2002 Malbec in hand, I first got in line to order my onion rings. There I met Gary Grace, another local who is retired and just comes for the fun of it. He brought along a 1995 Chateau Montelena which was soft and gentle in its aromas, teasing with berries and well-integrated vanilla. The initial flavor showed some sweetness, continuing on with the easy berry tannins. 

Ken FranksHeading to the corner table where Scott and his boss, La Toque’s owner, Ken Franks, were holding court, a decent crowd had already gathered and dozens of bottles were distributed on the tables. An easy-going free-for-all was underway with no organization and no formal pourings being arranged. I introduced myself and was told to jump in.  I immediately zeroed in on a French bottle and needed no encouragement; 2001 Margaux Pavillon Rouge; Dark and über rich with complex, earthy notes and hints of raspberry.

Ya got any onion rings with that?Then I spied an older, rare California offering as I grasped a 1991 Ridge Monte Bella Cabernet Sauvignon which was concentrated with dusty, elegant black cherry and teasing with hints of chocolate.

Monty Preiser and Joan ZolothNoting the fact that I was the only one in this august crowd taking tasting notes, Monty Preiser introduced himself as a Florida-based wine writer who was visiting for the summer. He is volunteering at the Culinary Institute’s Rudd Center for Wine Studies. Before we knew it, Joan Zoloth, who directs the wine program at the CIA had sidled up next to Monty for her first pour. 1999 Dominus Cabernet Sauvignon which showed dark chocolate and dark cherry and hints of dried floral and twigs. 

1961 Château Magdelaine with friesMany of us had our eyes on a very special red box which Scott had sequestered. He finally pulled out and displayed a bottle he had brought back from France just twelve hours before, a 1961 Château Magdelaine. It took some special handling in opening it. Bricky and ascending to tawny orange in color, this was a wine that displayed earthy and dark, musky qualities with depth of age and aromas that never, ever gave up. Fabulous pairing with the French fries. 

Adele and Dennis JohnsI happened upon a bottle 2001 White Cottage Cabernet Sauvignon and was introduced to owners Adele and Dennis Johns.  In the irreverent fashion this event demands, we all marveled that they imbibed their half-bottle selections from miniature, half-glasses. Dennis is known for his time with St. Clement Winery, but his special offering was integrated and soft with elegant fruit, showing amazing complexity with depth between some dark anise and dark blackberry. 

Robin MitchellThen, being introduced to Robin Mitchell of Paradigm, I accepted a pour from her bottle, a 2001 Paradigm Cabernet Sauvignon. After some of the intensely dark wines we had been drinking, I was surprised that this was a lighter offering with more herbal toned fruit. Complex and layered with bright green herbs and fresh fruit on the finish. 

The table was getting crowded with more bottles and more food  as I continued through more tasting, diligently attempting to make notes; 2001 Lang & Reed Cabernet Franc demonstrating fresh strawberry and oaky qualities with a dry mid-palate. 1999 Cordero Montezemolo Barolo; Bright and spicy with tantalizing pepper up front. Showed some minerality in the middle and a green herb on the end. 2001 Mongeard – Mugneret Vosne-Romanee; Sexy, sexy, sexy. Words completely escaped me and when Monty passed by me and I asked his opinion, neither of us could get past the fact that it was just amazing. Earthy aromas that were layered and stunning. Stunning mouth feel. Downright erotic.  2002 Etude Pinot Noir; Juicy, big mouthfeel with earthy raspberry entry and tantalizing smoky tease in the mid-palate.  

Jeff MorganMore food arrived and more bottles and more new friends as well. I was introduced to Jeff Morgan, a Renaissance man in his own right who now only makes wine under Covenant Winery, but is also known for his own wine writings. He and I shared even more tastes; 2002 Pride Merlot; Jammy with blackberry liqueur. Sweet entry blossomed and had an odd menthol finish. 2001 Spring Mountain Cabernet Sauvignon; Overwhelming green bell pepper and tinny mineral qualities overwhelmed.  

Getting ready to make my departure, I couldn’t resist a 2001 Gregory Graham Syrah; Blackberry liqueur with heaps of spice on the mid-palate and a chewy finish that continued well into the weekend. Lastly, being intimately familiar with Frank Dotzler’s work on Howell Mountain, my final taste of the event was the 2002 Outpost Zinfandel; Perfumed with dark floral and a port-like entry. Initially quite sweet but smooth and bright that expanded to show more spice. Lovely, sweet with fruit on the finish, and a lovely ending to an amazing day.

Previously from Carolyn Tillie:

Cal Co-op Tasting Rooms: Tasting on Main

BACK TO THE TOP

CAROLYN TILLIE'S HOME PAGE AND MAIN INDEX

© Carolyn Tillie - 2005  

Link to Gang of Pour Home Page

Link to Gang of Pour Site Index (Table of Contents)

     ©  Carolyn Tillie